Four fasts - minhag or halacha?

Updated: Mar 3

17th Tammuz, 9th Av, Tzom Gedaliah, 10th Tevet - what did Zechariya intend?


When don’t you fast? Rashi says when Jews are sovereign, Ramban says during Temple times. Are Jews sovereign today?

Ramban says a majority can decide not to fast. How do you apply this rule? The Rambam provides a simpler psak.


Part 1


Part 2



17 views0 comments